One of the features of RezoViz is that you can edit the list of nodes and connections. Here is my edit of the connections down to a weight of around 10. I removed some cases where people had multiple names or where people were mentioned authors who are not part of the community, like Mark Olsen connecting to Samuel Johnson.
Allen Renear -- Elaine Brennan {weight:58}
Ian Lancashire -- Willard McCarty {weight:55}
Susan Hockey -- Willard McCarty {weight:37}
Nancy Ide -- Susan Hockey {weight:35}
Nancy Ide -- Willard McCarty {weight:34}
Lou Burnard -- Willard McCarty {weight:34}
Michael Sperberg-McQueen -- Willard McCarty {weight:33}
Mark Olsen -- Willard McCarty {weight:33}
Arun-Kumar Tripathi -- Willard McCarty {weight:33}
Geoffrey Rockwell -- Willard McCarty {weight:33}
John Unsworth -- Willard McCarty {weight:29}
Antonio Zampolli -- Susan Hockey {weight:27}
Ian Hacking -- Willard McCarty {weight:27}
Jim Coombs -- Willard McCarty {weight:27}
John Lavagnino -- Willard McCarty {weight:27}
David Bearman -- Jennifer Trant {weight:26}
Charles Ess -- Fay Sudweeks {weight:25}
Allen Renear -- Willard McCarty {weight:25}
Stephen Ramsay -- Willard McCarty {weight:25}
Ray Siemens -- Willard McCarty {weight:25}
Antonio Zampolli -- Nancy Ide {weight:24}
Lou Burnard -- Michael Sperberg-McQueen {weight:22}
Patrick Durusau -- Willard McCarty {weight:22}
Arun Tripathi -- Willard McCarty {weight:21}
Morris Eaves -- Robert Essick {weight:20}
Julia Flanders -- Willard McCarty {weight:20}
David Sitman -- Willard McCarty {weight:20}
Elaine Brennan -- Susan Hockey {weight:20}
Ian Lancashire -- Susan Hockey {weight:20}
John Bradley -- Willard McCarty {weight:20}
Steve DeRose -- Willard McCarty {weight:19}
Francois Lachance -- Willard McCarty {weight:19}
Harold Short -- Willard McCarty {weight:19}
Roberto Busa -- Willard McCarty {weight:19}
Joseph Viscomi -- Robert Essick {weight:19}
Joseph Viscomi -- Morris Eaves {weight:19}
Lou Burnard -- Sebastian Rahtz {weight:18}
Antonio Zampolli -- Willard McCarty {weight:18}
Sebastian Rahtz -- Willard McCarty {weight:18}
Matt Kirschenbaum -- Willard McCarty {weight:18}
Antonio Zampolli -- Nicoletta Calzolari {weight:18}
Charles Faulhaber -- Willard McCarty {weight:18}
Antonio Zampolli -- Paul Fortier {weight:17}
Matthew Kirschenbaum -- Willard McCarty {weight:17}
Jerome McGann -- Willard McCarty {weight:17}
Peter Galison -- Willard McCarty {weight:17}
Paul Fortier -- Susan Hockey {weight:17}
Nancy Ide -- Paul Fortier {weight:17}
Elli Mylonas -- Willard McCarty {weight:17}
Joel Goldfield -- Willard McCarty {weight:16}
ohn Burrows -- Willard McCarty {weight:16}
Tito Orlandi -- Willard McCarty {weight:15}
Matthew Kirschenbaum -- Morris Eaves {weight:15}
Jean Veronis -- Nancy Ide {weight:15}
David Green -- Jennifer Trant {weight:15}
Marilyn Deegan -- Willard McCarty {weight:15}
Peter Shillingsburg -- Willard McCarty {weight:15}
Joseph Viscomi -- Matthew Kirschenbaum {weight:15}
Eve Trager -- Judith Axler Turner {weight:15}
Michael Mahoney -- Willard McCarty {weight:15}
Geoffrey Rockwell -- Julia Flanders {weight:14}
Matthew Kirschenbaum -- Robert Essick {weight:14}
Daniel Greenstein -- Nancy Ide {weight:14}
Lou Burnard -- Susan Hockey {weight:14}
Adrian Miles -- Willard McCarty {weight:14}
Paul Fortier -- Willard McCarty {weight:14}
Marilyn Deegan -- Susan Hockey {weight:14}
Nicolas Nicolov -- Ruslan Mitkov {weight:14}
Ian Lancashire -- Paul Fortier {weight:14}
John Hughes -- Willard McCarty {weight:14}
Ray Siemens -- Susan Schreibman {weight:14}
Bob Kraft -- Lou Burnard {weight:13}
Michael Sperberg-McQueen -- Nancy Ide {weight:13}
Ian Lancashire -- Lou Burnard {weight:13}
Wilhelm Ott -- Willard McCarty {weight:13}
Eric Johnson -- Ralph Griswold {weight:13}
Geoffrey Nunberg -- Willard McCarty {weight:13}
Carlos Areces -- Patrick Blackburn {weight:13}
Ian Lancashire -- Ray Siemens {weight:13}
John Unsworth -- Julia Flanders {weight:13}
Bob Kraft -- Willard McCarty {weight:13}
Geoffrey Rockwell -- Ray Siemens {weight:13}
Geoffrey Rockwell -- John Bradley {weight:13}
Jack Schofield -- Willard McCarty {weight:13}
Douglas Rushkoff -- Willard McCarty {weight:13}
Geoffrey Rockwell -- John Unsworth {weight:13}
Judith Axler Turner -- Thom Lieb {weight:13}
Clifford Lynch -- David Green {weight:13}
Antonio Zampolli -- Jacqueline Hamesse {weight:13}
James Morrison -- Stephen Downes {weight:13}
Michael Zock -- Ruslan Mitkov {weight:13}
Ian Lancashire -- Nancy Ide {weight:12}
Lisa Hopkins -- Sean Lawrence {weight:12}
Alan Morrison -- Lou Burnard {weight:12}
Geoffrey Rockwell -- Matthew Kirschenbaum {weight:12}
Jacqueline Hamesse -- Paul Fortier {weight:12}
Jerome McGann -- John Unsworth {weight:12}
B. Wolff Modern -- Mark Wolff {weight:12}
Lou Burnard -- Nancy Ide {weight:12}
Clifford Geertz -- Willard McCarty {weight:12}
David Green -- Howard Besser {weight:12}
Wendell Piez -- Willard McCarty {weight:12}
Allen Renear -- Susan Hockey {weight:12}
Jacqueline Hamesse -- Susan Hockey {weight:12}
Gordon Dixon -- Susan Hockey {weight:12}
James O'Donnell -- Willard McCarty {weight:12}
Jacqueline Hamesse -- Nancy Ide {weight:12}
Marilyn Deegan -- Stuart Lee {weight:12}
Allen Renear -- Elli Mylonas {weight:12}
Julia Flanders -- Wendell Piez {weight:12}
Ian Lancashire -- Michael Sperberg-McQueen {weight:12}
David Hilbert -- Willard McCarty {weight:12}
Malcolm Brown -- Willard McCarty {weight:12}
David Hoover -- Willard McCarty {weight:12}
Geoffrey Rockwell -- Susan Hockey {weight:12}
Claire Warwick -- Susan Schreibman {weight:12}
Julia Flanders -- Ray Siemens {weight:12}
Nancy Ide -- Nicoletta Calzolari {weight:12}
Allen Renear -- Lou Burnard {weight:12}
Peter Robinson -- Willard McCarty {weight:12}
Don Fowler -- Willard McCarty {weight:12}
Nancy Ide -- Randall Jones {weight:11}
Stanley Katz -- Willard McCarty {weight:11}
Elaine Brennan -- Willard McCarty {weight:11}
Matthew Kirschenbaum -- Neil Fraistat {weight:11}
Manfred Thaller -- Willard McCarty {weight:11}
Lou Burnard -- Michael Fraser {weight:11}
James Joyce -- Louis Armand {weight:11}
Antonio Zampolli -- Lou Burnard {weight:11}
Allen Renear -- David Sitman {weight:11}
Julia Flanders -- Matthew Kirschenbaum {weight:11}
Terry Winograd -- Willard McCarty {weight:11}
David Chesnutt -- Willard McCarty {weight:11}
Robin Cover -- Willard McCarty {weight:11}
Jennifer Trant -- Maxwell Anderson {weight:11}
Gordon Dixon -- Joel Goldfield {weight:11}
Susan Schreibman -- Willard McCarty {weight:11}
James Wilderotter II -- Jim Wilderotter {weight:11}
Julia Flanders -- Susan Schreibman {weight:11}
Antonio Zampolli -- Michael Neuman {weight:11}
Harold Short -- Lou Burnard {weight:11}
Geoffrey Rockwell -- Ian Lancashire {weight:11}
Robert Essick -- William Blake {weight:11}
John Lavagnino -- Julia Flanders {weight:11}
Morris Eaves -- William Blake {weight:11}
Darrell Raymond -- Willard McCarty {weight:11}
Amit Kumar -- Susan Schreibman {weight:11}
John Searle -- Willard McCarty {weight:11}
David Gants -- Willard McCarty {weight:11}
Alan Burk -- David Seaman {weight:11}
Elli Mylonas -- Susan Hockey {weight:11}
Paul Groves -- Stuart Lee {weight:11}
Charles Ess -- Herbert Hrachovec {weight:10}
Antonio Zampolli -- Christian Delcourt {weight:10}
Antonio Zampolli -- Gordon Dixon {weight:10}
Michael Zock -- Nicolas Nicolov {weight:10}
Charles Ess -- Susan Herring {weight:10}
Daniel O'Donnell -- Daniel Paul O'Donnell {weight:10}
Norman Zacour -- Willard McCarty {weight:10}
David Durand -- Willard McCarty {weight:10}
Joel Goldfield -- Nancy Ide {weight:10}
David Erdman -- William Blake {weight:10}
Antonio Zampolli -- Khalid Choukri {weight:10}
Joseph Viscomi -- William Blake {weight:10}
Robert Kraft -- Willard McCarty {weight:10}
Bob Kraft -- Robin Cover {weight:10}
Paul Mc Kevitt -- Yorick Wilks {weight:10}
Gregory Bateson -- Willard McCarty {weight:10}
David Sitman -- Nancy Ide {weight:10}
Karine Lawrence -- Sean Lawrence {weight:10}
Gordon Dixon -- Nancy Ide {weight:10}
Martin Holmes -- Victoria Humanities {weight:10}
Greg Lessard -- Willard McCarty {weight:10}
Alex Enkerli -- Alexandre Enkerli {weight:10}
Nicoletta Calzolari -- Yorick Wilks {weight:10}
Ruslan Mitkov -- Tony McEnery {weight:10}
Christine Sundt -- Robert Baron {weight:10}
Elaine Brennan -- Lou Burnard {weight:10}
Elaine Brennan -- Nancy Ide {weight:10}
Ruslan Mitkov -- Yorick Wilks {weight:10}
Eve Trager -- Thom Lieb {weight:10}
Ian Lancashire -- Peter Robinson {weight:10}
John Unsworth -- Ray Siemens {weight:10}
David Green -- Kenneth Crews {weight:10}
Lorna Hughes -- Willard McCarty {weight:10}
George Landow -- Willard McCarty {weight:10}
Ian Lancashire -- John Lavagnino {weight:10}
Today Stéfan and I resumed our analytical sessions. We concentrated on using RezoViz with Humanist. RezoViz is a network analysis tool that Stéfan and implemented. He has written a post on RezoViz here.
We found that interpretatively it made sense to start with a low number for the "max people" and to build up seeing who is added. At about 50 for all years I started editing the list to get rid of the situations where Geoff Rockwell was closely linked to Geoffrey Rockwell.
Using this reminded me of people important to humanities computing in previous decades who have disappeared like Elaine Brennan who edited Humanist for a while with Allen Renear.
We decided in the end not to put the network anaysis of humanist into the example chapter on humanist. We want to keep the example chapters simple and short. Instead we are going to try it on Game Studies to see if that would make an interesting example.
We got feeback on our prospectus and it is positive! Hurrah! Now we have to continue writing.
One suggestion was that we have some more examples so we are thinking about what we could try. Here is a list:
Having sent out the prospectus (and keeping our fingers crossed) we are now turning back to the second experiment tentatively called "The Swallow Flies Swiftly Through." The idea is to try to understand humanities computing / digital analysis using text analysis. This uses Humanist as a corpus so it lets us work with a large corpus. It also forced us to think about how to do diachronic analysis. By creating a corpus from each year and naming them right we can get distribution graphs over time. We also, with support from the Digging Into Data challenge, developed a correspondence analysis tool that works well.
One way we are studying the corpus is looking at the words (across the corpus) that have a skew one way or another. The idea is to look for words trending up or down. Here is a simple skin I developed for going through the words with the distribution tool and KWICA concordance or keyword in context (KWIC) is usually represented as a list of occurrences of a word with some limited context shown (words to the left and words to the right). Here is an example that shows the occurrences of the word "dream" in A Midsummer Night's Dream in TACTweb: I.1/577.1 | Four nights will quickly dream away the time; | And I.1/578.2 Swift as a shadow, short as any dream; | Brief as the II.2/585.1 | Ay me, for pity! what a dream was here! | Lysander, III.2/591.1 this derision | Shall seem a dream and fruitless vision, | IV.1/593.1 as the fierce vexation of a dream. | But first I will IV.1/594.2 to me | That yet we sleep, we dream. Do not you think | The IV.1/594.2 rare | vision. I have had a dream, past the wit of man to IV.1/594.2 the wit of man to | say what dream it was: man is but an IV.1/594.2 he go | about to expound this dream. Methought I was--there IV.1/594.2 his heart to report, what my dream | was. I will get Peter IV.1/594.2 to write a ballad of | this dream: it shall be called IV.1/594.2 it shall be called Bottom's dream, | because it hath no V.1/599.1 | Following darkness like a dream, | Now are frolic: not a V.1/599.2 theme, | No more yielding but a dream, | Gentles, do not See also the definition at Wikipedia. Return to Glossary. for checking.
By playing with the settings (set TAPoRware stopwords and a Z-score of 2 or more) I can narrow the list of words down and then go through them manually.
Some things I need:
Over the last couple of weeks we have had discussions about changing the name. It was pointed out to us that there are no positive senses to the word "voyeur" in English. As much as we may like the "cheeky" and visual sense of the name, it bothers many who use the tool, which was never our aim. So ... after talking with some fold we are changing the name to Voyant which in French means clairvoyant, witness, informant, gaudy, light and visible.
Now we are working with Milena to get a new graphic design.
I've gone through the online version of Now, Analyze That. Some fixes:
Stuff now to do for the Word version.
Other stuff:
We had a Skype today and a general discussion on getting hermeneuti.ca back on track. We found a way to escape glossary entries. Enter ... . Some other decisions:
What has to be done to send out the prospectus?
Other things that need doing:
Who do we send it to:
I taught a half-day workshop on Voyeur today in Dublin at the From Metadata to Linked Data conference. (See my conference report at http://www.philosophi.ca/pmwiki.php/Main/FromMetadataToLinkedData ) Here are some thoughts on what worked and didn't.
Based on the workshop, here are some desirable features that came up: